Why Voting is a Public Health Issue

Who the Health Cares? Podcast Season 3, Episode 3

*MUSIC*

 

I'm Michael Sparer, the director of the Center for Public Health Implementation at Columbia University. You're listening to Who the Health Cares, a podcast about the US public health system, what it is, who does what, and why all of us should care about it. My guest today is Dr. Avenel Joseph, vice president of policy for the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

Avenel began her career as a scientist, earning a PhD in cell and molecular biology before moving into public policy. She then spent nearly 12 years working on Capitol Hill, where she saw firsthand how politics shapes the decisions that affect Americans' health. Today, she drives the policy agenda at the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, the nation's largest healthcare foundation.

Avenel and I talked about the relationship between politics and public health and why scientific evidence alone is rarely enough to produce good policy. We also discussed what she calls the, quote, "political determinants of health," including how voting and civic engagement can influence health outcomes and the challenges facing our underfunded and undervalued public health system.

Heads up, listeners. Avenel and I sat down for this chat shortly before the midterm elections. Yes, the midterm elections that produced a blue wave, a Democratic Congress, and a remarkable shift in American politics. You can be sure that we'll be following and talking about the changed political dynamics down the line.

But after listening to Avenel, you'll have a better sense of why the unexpected election winners included public health officials, physicians, and scientists. Here's my conversation with Dr. Avenel Joseph.

Avenel: I grew up in Queens, New York, very diverse community. My mom was in the healthcare system. She was a nurse. And I remember seeing so many people in my community that were affected by all kinds of health issues that didn't seem to be explainable by genetics alone. And that question really followed me into my scientific training.

I thought when I was younger that I wanted to be a veterinarian to sort of diagnose really, um, complex things that were happening in animals. And that I did do my undergraduate study in animal sciences sort of on a pre-vet path. But a- along the way, I decided that I wanted to study more about how cells evolve and how they become what they become, and how they're impacted by the environment around them.

So I did a Master's of Science in Developmental Toxicology and a PhD in Cell and Molecular Biology. My PhD research really focused on what exposures to certain chemicals could do to cells, to developing cells. I think as I was doing my PhD research and going through the normal, you know, you do your, your bench research, you do your dissertation, you do your postdoc.

And I was looking at what the options were for my future, which was at the time to do academia, um, be an academic scientist, or go and work for industry to develop drugs or some other sort of products for human consumption. I just, um, I didn't really love those options. And, um, I took a chance on a congressional fellowship, uh, that was aimed at bringing scientists to the Hill to help inform federal policymaking.

It was a one-year fellowship, and I caught the bug. Um, that one-year fellowship In policy turned into a nearly 12-year career, uh, working on Capitol Hill as a staffer. 

Michael: So when you think back on those days and your, your early work on the fellowship and then your, your early work on the Hill more generally, what did you learn about sort of the connection between science and politics?

I mean, how did those two worlds interact? Uh, here you were a scientist now working in policy. How did you find the reaction you got to scientific evidence, and what, what produced policy, and where did the science fit in? 

Avenel: So that was the whole aim of this, um, fellowship that I was a part of, was a recognition that Congress was often legislating really complex environmental and scientific questions, and it was being done by English majors and lawyers, which, you know, is not bad in of itself, but there was- 

Michael: As, as an ex-lawyer myself, I can tell you it's not the best thing in the world, yeah.

Avenel: You know, it was, it was this recognition that having some sort of scientific expertise would be really helpful to produce better legislation and better science policy. You know, I think what I will say about my time is, you know, scientific training really grounded me in the importance of rigorous data.

Um, you know, you can't understand what is needed and what the problem is without being able to see the data. But I think on the Hill, what I learned was that just having that evidence alone wasn't enough. Research could inform the laws and the budgets and the systems, um, but those systems ultimately are gonna determine how that evidence gets translated into people's lives.

And often who was influencing what was gonna end up in legislation were people who had particular interests at heart, um, and typically those were sort of corporate interests and how they were gonna be preserved in the process. 

Michael: Do you think scientists, and here maybe I'll include public health scientists, uh, in, in the conversation, too often get frustrated that policymakers and politicians don't just sort of hear the evidence that they're providing and say, uh, "Okay, we'll turn that evidence into policy"?

Do you think public health and the scientific community, um, what do they need to learn and what do they misunderstand, do you think, at times about politics? 

Avenel: I think that, um, there is a maybe misunderstanding or just a lack of understanding of what shapes policy generation. It is not data alone or hard numbers data.

It is that, of course, but it is also how people are experiencing a particular problem. So it is stories, and that could be the stories of how it's impacting community and people's health, or it could be the story of how a law is impacting a corporate bottom line. And how that gets communicated to policymakers and how they're contextualizing that in the context of the people that they're supposed to be there to represent is a hugely important part of how decisions are getting made.

And ignoring that and thinking data alone is gonna be the thing that answers the question or makes the thing happen, I think is a vast under, uh, estimate of how the process really works and really just ends up making people very frustrated, um, when they don't understand there's a much bigger picture there.

Michael: So let's shift gears and really talk about politics and, and public health right now and health more generally. Uh, you know, there's been, over the last 10, 15 years, there's been increased attention by everybody, I think, in the healthcare arena to the, quote-unquote, "social determinants of health": your income, your race, your education, where you live.

But you've also been talking about, in addition to the social determinants, what you and others, uh, are calling these days the, the political determinants of health. Tell me a little about what the term political determinants of health means to you, uh, and, and why it's so important. 

Avenel: So the political determinants of health, um, is a term that was actually coined by one of my favorite people in the world, Professor Daniel Dawes, and it essentially establishes that social conditions such as housing quality, neighborhood safety, environmental pollution Transportation access.

So all of the social determinants of health are actually downstream effects that are rooted in the upstream political choices that people are making. So in essence, the process of, uh, participating in voting, electing, and choosing particular elected officials are what help shape the environment in which your health is being cultivated in.

And if we don't pay attention to that, we might be fighting a even a, a bigger battle and one where we're not really seeing what the opposition truly is. 

Michael: It reminds me, um, when you think about the definition of politics that I learned, uh, probably on my first day as a, a PhD political science, uh, um, doctoral student, uh, is that politics is about who gets what, when, why, and how.

Uh, and in a certain sense, I think what Dr. Dawes and you and others are talking about are taking that, that basic definition of politics and saying that's equally relevant, uh, in the field of health, which it historically has not been viewed by many as being quite as relevant, I think, and try to bring that more to the fore.

Avenel: Absolutely. And I think, um, it's both the choice of who is going to be in these elected roles and what sort of initiatives you might be supporting or not supporting in a ballot, for example, that might impact your health But it's even broader than that, in that voting itself is an act that will help us connect better with neighborhoods, be a part of community, build trust with institutions, and all of those things have measurable impacts on the quality of our life and how long we live.

Michael: Say a little more, and you're the, the scientist with the background in biology, um, you know, a little more about the physical impact, it sounds like, the physical, mental impact that voting has. Is it the feeling of ownership and inclusion? I mean, what is it actually that, that makes voting such an important part of, of, of our health?

Avenel: It is the act of civic participation. So voting is one, uh, manifestation of civic participation. You can also have civic participation by being very active in a local church or in your school community, in your local community center, but the process of being civically engaged connects you to your neighbors.

I mean, it's not rocket science, okay? People do study this, and that boosts people's mental health. It boosts their well-being. It boosts their sense of agency, and all of that has, um, measurable impacts in the improvement of health. And on the contrary, I think the really important thing is what we know is that when you have really restrictive voting processes, when you are stripping people of their agency, when you are restricting their ability to sort of step into what is their civic responsibility, it has significant detrimental impacts on their health and the health of all of their community.

And so I think the argument that I will make is voting is a central health issue. Whether people can participate, be represented, influence their public policy decisions will shape the conditions that they live in, and the very act of participating in civic responsibility and voting improves your health.

Michael: Well, that's a really important point to make, especially as we head into midterm elections, as we're in the midst of a season these days in which, uh, the administration in Washington, D.C. and the courts, uh, the Supreme Court and others, have actually put in place or are trying to put in place initiatives that make it harder to vote. I mean, is that how you're saying what's going on now and, and what's the implication of that, and where do you think that's going? 

Avenel: Yes. I mean, I, I do think that there have been both, um, state-by-state efforts as well as federal administrative efforts aimed at trying to restrict people's ability to vote.

And what we know about the connection between that and health is that communities that have more restrictive voting practices have experienced worse health outcomes. Research has shown that strong democratic conditions, including civic participation, are very closely linked to better health and wellbeing.

In states where voting is more accessible, they report better mental health, fewer uninsured residents, lower infant mortality, and, uh, that's in addition to, uh, the fact that states that have these more inclusive and accessible voting policies are significantly more likely to adopt policies like Medicaid expansion, just for example, that directly impact health outcomes and public health priorities 

Michael: It sounds like it's a two-way street though. I mean, voting improves your health, but things that happen in society that hurt your health, like getting kicked off Medicaid, for example, or losing Medicaid when you're really eligible, or being pushed out of the ACA marketplaces, those probably also impact your interest and mental desire to vote. I mean, it, it sounds like they both impact each other.

Avenel: Absolutely. It is a mutually reinforcing cycle for sure. I mean, one, one thing that you can take as sort of a case example are ballot measures. So not every state allows, uh, direct democracy or citizen-initiated ballot measures where people actually vote on policies directly, but there are 24-ish states that do allow that.

And what we have seen in, uh, recent years is that through these state and local ballot measures, we have seen advancement in policies like minimum wage increases, the creation of paid leave programs, guaranteeing the right to abortion and other forms of reproductive healthcare, universal childcare, progressive tax structures.

So in the past decade alone, ballot measures have helped to advance health equity amid a time when state legislatures alone have become both increasingly polarized, which has made it harder for them to pass policies of any type, and when they are able to pass something in a state house and through the regular order, it is usually more restrictive on health 

Michael: Do you worry a little bit at times, though? I, I wanna ask that. I mean, direct democracy is great, but direct democracy sometimes results in the majority taking advantage and discriminating against the minority, and that's why we then have courts who come in to have to protect the rights of the minority. 

So we have seen some direct democracy situations in which there have been voter initiatives restricting the right of immigrants, for example. Do you worry a little about them and that piece of it in the back of your head also? 

Avenel: It's definitely a double-edged sword. I think what we are seeing far more of in these days are attempts to restrict the use of ballot measures at all. And why is that happening? It's happening because people across political ideologies are coming together to pass policies that mean something for their communities, and state legislatures don't like that.

And they are trying to make it more and more restrictive and more and more easy for the ballot process to be co-opted by others than those that it is intended for, which are the citizens of that particular community. And so, yes, I mean, there is always the possibility of ballot initiatives being used to pass something that is inequitable, but I would argue that the ability for communities to organize, to get educated, and to then exercise their right to vote have s- uh, very impactful health outcomes that outweigh the potential negative of, of the ballot being something that we don't like.

Michael: Let me shift gears a little bit. Um, we have a extraordinarily fragmented and decentralized public health system in the United States. We've obviously got the CDC and the FDA and federal agencies, but then we have, uh, 3,300 state and local health departments, uh, with very different organizational structures, very different fiscal capacity, very different ways in which they view their mission at times.

Um, almost all of them under-resourced and underfunded, uh, as well. How do you think the, the fragmented nature of public health, what kind of impact does that have on the politics of public health? 

Avenel: Oh, this is a great question. What I will say is that public health has long been starved from the resources that it needed. That is not a new phenomenon. And it's only been complicated by public health not always making the best case for why it's needed and why it matters to the public. It has gone, I think, through extreme denigration over the last few years, not just because of this administration's approach to public health and as much of it's defunding it and politicizing it, but also in the post-COVID era where things weren't handled as great as they could have been, and public health institutions have sort of, um, they bear some responsibility for that.

What I will say is that in this new era, we have regional hubs that are popping up of public health practitioners and agencies in particular regions of the United States where there's now information sharing that's happening across borders, communication guidance that's coming out in a coordinated way for a particular region, and I think that's really powerful and perhaps is a future of what public health will be, one that is more closely grounded and rooted in the community that it serves and is oriented towards that community and its surrounding communities in a way that has real meaning and is able to build more trust to the people that it serves.

Michael: Yeah. I mean, there certainly are efforts in most states, I think, around the country these days to basically ask or, in fact, require their local health departments both to do community health assessments but also to do community health improvement plans that build off of, you know, what the community feels are the most important public health priorities in their own community.

Avenel: So important, and I think that shift is the future of public health. 

Michael: Let's shift gears a little. I mean, you were a scientist, then you worked on the Hill, and then you went to work, uh, for the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation as the vice president for policy. Many of our listeners probably know all about RWJ, uh, Robert Wood Johnson, but not all of them.

Maybe take a moment and just tell us a little bit about the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, its mission, the kind of work it does, and your role as vice president of policy. 

Avenel: Sure. So the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation is a national health funder whose mission and vision is to create a country where health is no longer a privilege but a right.

And that takes us recognizing that health is not just the absence of disease, and that there are many barriers to achieving good health For most of RWJF's history, we focused on public health and healthcare, somewhat siloed actually from each other. Early on, we focused on improving access to healthcare for infants and elder care, mental health, emergency services.

And then I think over time came to understand, uh, that health isn't shaped by just the hospitals or clinics, but it's shaped by the structures of society itself or the social determinants of health, the political determinants of health. And what anchors our approach to health these days is a clear understanding that health inequities are not accidental.

They are the result of policy choices. They are the result of intentional and unintentional barriers that have been erected for some and not for all, and that the system of health itself has historically excluded many communities. Recognizing that I think has really reshaped RWJF's mission, uh, the way that we do our work.

Uh, we focus now on policies that break down some of those structural barriers that are in people's ways and open doors for those who may have been left out. Sometimes we are playing offense and we're really thinking about how can we create expanded civil rights and health rights. And unfortunately, in lots of cases, especially right now, we're playing a lot of, of defense as, as well.

I think I'll give, um, maybe one example. It's about healthcare, and it's gonna start with a story of myself, so it- because it's helped me realize just how complicated our healthcare system can be. I have very good employer-sponsored health insurance, including out-of-network coverage. I met my deductible last year, and for 10 months now, I have been fighting with an insurance company that has refused to pay my out-of-network claims.

I've probably spent more than 25 hours on this, calling during lunch breaks, in the evenings, in the mornings, talked to people in the claims department, argued my case over and over and over again. And every time I get a representative, once I finally do get a human, which in of itself takes too long- You know?

Michael: I mean, some of this is sounding very familiar, I have to tell you. But go ahead. 

Avenel: I, I'm telling you, it's, it's familiar to everybody You know, I get representatives, humans that finally tell me, "You are absolutely right. Your plan covers this. We should be, um, paying for this, and we should be sending you a check." And here I am, you know, 10 months later and still waiting. And I think this example sticks with me because of exactly what you just said. 

Everybody has their story that's just like that, and some of us, like me, understand that this is a complicated healthcare system, understands that I can push back on it and argue my case, understands, um, how to do that, and has the luxury of spending 25 hours of my life to try to get an insurance company to pay for something that they're supposed to already have been doing.

Michael: And that they've agreed that they're supposed to be doing. 

Avenel: And that they've agreed that they are supposed to be doing. And so what does that mean for people who don't have that extra disposable time, who can't take the time off of work, who don't even have a lunch break to be able to call on, who don't understand the intricacies of their plan and what should be paid for and what's not? Not to mention the people who don't have insurance at all or who have very inadequate insurance. 

Michael: And that number's growing, and it's gonna continue to grow. 

Avenel: And the number is growing and growing. And I think ultimately this is a healthcare system that is overcharging people and making it too hard for people to get the care that they want.

And RWJF has launched a, uh, campaign called One Nation Overcharged, and the whole purpose of this campaign is to get everyday Americans engaged in the platform to tell their stories about how they are delaying or skipping care, or being overcharged, or taking on medical debt, or stretching their budgets just to be able to, uh, get some basic healthcare coverage.

We have a healthcare system that puts the burden on people to navigate and to fight their own way through a system that's supposed to be working for them. And at RWJF, we're supporting an avenue for people to have their voices heard and to activate them to demand something different from a system that is supposed to work for them. And it's a really an, a- an exciting, um, campaign that we're very proud of. 

Michael: Let me, and I'm not sure what you can say about this and what you can't, 'cause I'm not asking you to endorse a particular politician or party or anyo- anyone in particular, but in a very general sense, how important would you say the midterm elections are, and what impact would it have for public health, do you think, if in fact the Democrats took over Congress?

Avenel: Well, what I can say is that people pay too much attention to presidential elections to the detriment of midterm elections. They are incredibly important, not just because of what will happen in the federal landscape, but because that is where, um, you are able to elect your state's governor, your state house representatives and senators.

And so no matter who is on the ballot, midterm elections are incredibly important, and people should be getting out to vote because voting is important for your health. That being said, I think we are at an incredible inflection point for healthcare and healthcare affordability. There's not a time that I remember in recent history where everybody is unhappy with health, their healthcare.

It doesn't matter if you have great private health insurance like I do, if you are on Medicaid, which is, like, less and less people now because of some of the, um, impacts of the bill called HR1 from earlier in the year People are generally unhappy for the value of healthcare that they're getting for what they are paying.

And so healthcare is gonna be a major factor on how Americans vote. It is part of a overall equation of how people are affording their monthly bills. Rent is going up, gas is going up, price of groceries have gone up, healthcare is going up, and all of that is gonna be a part of how Americans will decide on what they want to see happen, uh, during this midterm elections.

It's also worth just noting from a public health perspective, again, post-Dobbs, most of the action that will help us increase access to reproductive care is gonna happen as a result of state elections, either because of direct ballots or because of state legislative action that is shaped by the people who are elected during the midterms. So I think public health and health generally, it's very much on the ballot in the midterm elections. 

Michael: Yeah. Well, as you said, there are, in addition to congressional elections, I think there are 36 gubernatorial elections going on now, and then everything from the, uh, state senate and state, you know, legislative elections to city council elections, which actually, you know, when you think about those 3,000 local health departments that we were talking about, uh, those public health workers actually report to their local city council, their local county executive, et cetera. Uh, and that's who sets their budget, that's who sets their, their mission. Um, and public health happens on the ground in those communities. 

Avenel: That's absolutely right, and that's where people need to stay listening, involved, and activated because it is really what makes or breaks public health. 

Michael: You know, I teach in a school of public health. I've been here a little over 30 years. Um, so I'm always talking to new public health students and, and young people and some older people who are interested in, in careers in public health, despite the fact that public health is under-resourced, uh, underpaid and under financed, and oftentimes misunderstood and mistrusted.

And, you know, it's not easy being on the front lines often as a public health worker. And yet, um, our students are here. I mean, if, is there something that you would, a message that you would wanna give to sort of public health students about public health politics and about sort of the, you know, the sort of mix of data and values and politics that we've been talking about here? What, what would be a message that you might wanna convey to the next generation of public health professionals? 

Avenel: I think it is the same as what I, I just said. You know, government is a stimulus response organization. It responds only when it is stimulated to do so, and it is the people who make it do something different.

And I think our young students that are in the public health field, they're very clear-eyed of what the problems are, where the field itself has gone wrong, where government could do better, and I think the more engaged they are, the better the future will certainly be. I also think that those students who are interested in, in public health fields are often like, "Well, what will I actually do? Like, what will my job be?" Yeah. And I- 

Michael: And what skills do I need? What are the skills that I really need? 

Avenel: And what skills do I need? Um- Yeah ... I think that the critical thinking, the ability to ask the difficult questions, analyzing data, all of these skills are ones that are translatable to many different types of employment and jobs.

And I think sometimes people, much like myself when I was a scientist, a bench scientist, and I was like, "Okay, well my only role in life will ever to be a bench scientist in one capacity or another," in reality, you know, a degree in public health opens up so many doors. You can go the policy route. There is a dire need for more public health communicators, um, people who can translate, um, into compelling writing, public health, uh, materials and ideas. And so I think the, the field of possibilities are really quite open for those who feel like this field is a calling for them. 

Michael: Well, thank you very much. This has really been a, a privilege for me, uh, to get the chance to have to chat with you, and I really appreciate the work that you do. Uh, and keep on doing it. It's really important. 

Avenel: Thank you so much, Michael. This has been such an honor, and I really enjoyed our conversation.

*MUSIC*

That was Dr. Avenel Joseph, vice president for policy for the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. Couple of thoughts before I close out the episode. For starters, Avenel rightly points out how politics not only shapes our health system, it also shapes the non-medical determinants of our health, such as our access to affordable housing, nutritious food, and clean air.

Second point, there's another key part of the political determinants of health that Avenel emphasizes. Put simply, voting. Yes, voting itself is a form of civic engagement that in and of itself is good for our health regardless of the outcome of a particular election. Point three, I found myself fascinated by Avenel's career path, her shift from an academic focus on cell and molecular biology to a dozen years on the Hill to her current role at the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

Few people are more qualified to talk about how data alone is not enough to shape good health policy. Instead, as Avenel emphasizes, we need stories. We need to humanize the data. We need to make people care. Finally, I found myself nodding in agreement as Avenel described her ongoing battle with what felt to her to be an endless and almost futile battle with a faceless healthcare bureaucracy.

My guess is that all of us have had similar experiences. It's these shared experiences which, taken together, have prompted the deep dissatisfaction with the healthcare system that is so widespread and yet seemingly so hard for us to address. I need to add, however, that for me at least, the midterm elections last week have prompted hope.

Hope that we might indeed move slowly but surely toward a better health system, a more effective and equitable health system, and a health system we can be proud of. And with that more hopeful note, we come to the end of this episode of Who the Health Cares?, a podcast that's doing its best to get the word out about what public health does and why it's so important.

Join me in two weeks when I talk to Dr. Dan Edney, the health officer for the state of Mississippi, a state that is among the nation's poorest, a state that has some of the nation's worst health outcomes, but also a state that has a strong public health leadership and some hopeful success stories of its own.

Till then, this is Michael Sparer signing off from the Center for Public Health Implementation at Columbia University.

The “Who the Health Cares” production team includes: Zoe Denckla, Rachel Ferat, Grace Rubin, Rebecca Sale, and Alex Weaver. Thanks to all of you!

 

Back to top